Skip to main content

Install RediHealth

Add RediHealth to your device for quick access.

  1. Click the install button in the address bar or open the browser menu.
  2. Select install RediHealth and confirm to open it in its own window.

3 min read, 3 min audio

What is overdiagnosis?

Overdiagnosis means finding a condition that would never have caused symptoms or harm during a person's life, and then treating it. It happens when tests detect real abnormalities that are not dangerous. It can lead to unnecessary worry, treatment and side effects, so it is important to know about it.

Key takeaway: Overdiagnosis means finding a condition that would never have caused symptoms or harm during a person's life, and then treating it. It happens when tests detect real abnormalities that are not dangerous. It can lead to unnecessary worry, treatment and side effects, so it is important to know about it.

Editorial draft: independent clinical and language review is pending. This information cannot diagnose symptoms or replace individual medical advice.

On this page

How it happens

More sensitive tests, such as scans and screening, find many small abnormalities. Some cancers grow so slowly or not at all, and some people die of other causes before the condition would ever matter. Doctors cannot always tell which abnormalities will cause harm, so many are treated to be safe. Widening the definition of a disease also creates more diagnoses.

Examples

Overdiagnosis is recognised in some cancers found by screening, such as certain breast, prostate and thyroid cancers, and in conditions where the thresholds have been lowered, such as borderline blood pressure or prediabetes. Incidental findings on scans, such as small thyroid nodules, are common and usually harmless.

Harms and benefits

People who are overdiagnosed can suffer anxiety, labelling, additional tests, operations, radiation or medicine with side effects, without benefit. Tests and screening still save lives for many, so the question is balance. The harm of overdiagnosis is hard to measure because it cannot be seen in an individual case.

What you can do

Ask whether a test is really needed, what could happen with the results, and what the possibilities are if something is found, including careful watching. For some findings, active surveillance with regular checks is a safe alternative to immediate treatment. Understanding the numbers helps you decide.

Considering screening

Before screening, think about benefits such as earlier detection, and drawbacks such as false alarms and overdiagnosis. Official information leaflets lay out these points. You are free to decide whether to take part.

Practical examples

These hypothetical situations illustrate decisions and questions. They do not predict a diagnosis or treatment result.

Weighing a test

Imagine you are offered a screening test. You could ask how many people benefit and how many are overdiagnosed.

Considering watchful waiting

Suppose a scan finds a small nodule. You might ask whether it can be monitored instead of removed.

Questions to ask your healthcare team

  • Do I need this test, and what will we do with the result?
  • Is careful monitoring a safe alternative to treatment?
  • What are the possible harms of screening?

Questions about your health?

Talk to a volunteer doctor in a voice call. It is free and confidential.

Talk to a doctor

Don't need a doctor?

A pharmacist can advise you for free, without an appointment.

Nearest pharmacy

This guide does not replace a doctor. This page gives you health information. It does not give you a diagnosis or treatment. For that, see a doctor. In an emergency, call 112.

Sources and further reading

Original RediHealth educational article. The examples are hypothetical. This is not a reproduction of an IQWiG article or an endorsement by IQWiG.

The source material is in English. Information about German healthcare services may not apply in other countries.