Systematic searches for evidence
To judge whether a treatment works, it is not enough to look at one study or at the studies that happen to be easy to find. A systematic search looks for all relevant research in a planned, repeatable way. Knowing how this works helps you understand why some summaries are more trustworthy than others.
Key takeaway: To judge whether a treatment works, it is not enough to look at one study or at the studies that happen to be easy to find. A systematic search looks for all relevant research in a planned, repeatable way. Knowing how this works helps you understand why some summaries are more trustworthy than others.
Editorial draft: independent clinical and language review is pending. This information cannot diagnose symptoms or replace individual medical advice.
On this page
Why searching systematically matters
Studies with positive results are more likely to be published and noticed than those with negative results. A reviewer who chooses studies casually may end up with a biased picture. A systematic search aims to avoid this by identifying as much of the relevant evidence as possible, regardless of its results.
Planning the question
The first step is a clear question, for example which people are of interest, which treatment is compared with what, and which outcomes matter. Researchers write down in advance which studies will be included and excluded, such as study type, population and time period, so that decisions are not influenced by the results.
Searching many sources
Searchers use several databases of medical literature, combining many search terms and synonyms. They also check trial registries for unpublished or ongoing studies, reference lists of key articles, conference reports and contact experts or manufacturers. The search strategy is documented so that others can repeat it.
Selecting and checking studies
Two people independently screen titles and abstracts, then full texts, against the inclusion criteria. Disagreements are resolved by discussion. The number of studies found and excluded, and reasons, are reported, often in a flow diagram. Then each included study is assessed for quality and risk of bias.
Limits and good practice
No search finds everything, and some evidence stays unpublished. Good reviews are transparent about how they searched and where gaps remain. When you read a summary of research, look for a description of how studies were identified, the dates of the search, and whether the review is up to date.
Practical examples
These hypothetical situations illustrate decisions and questions. They do not predict a diagnosis or treatment result.
Judging a review
Imagine a health website claims that research proves a treatment works. You could check whether the claim is based on a systematic review and how studies were found.
Asking a doctor
Suppose you read conflicting studies. You might ask your doctor whether a systematic review or guideline has summarised all the research on the question.
Questions to ask your healthcare team
- Is this claim based on all the relevant studies or only some?
- Is there a recent systematic review on this question?
- How up to date is this evidence?
Questions about your health?
Talk to a volunteer doctor in a voice call. It is free and confidential.
Don't need a doctor?
A pharmacist can advise you for free, without an appointment.
This guide does not replace a doctor. This page gives you health information. It does not give you a diagnosis or treatment. For that, see a doctor. In an emergency, call 112.